The Best Duvet Comforters: Top 7 Picks
Duvet comforters can add an amazing sense of coziness to any bedroom. They are warming, fluffy, and built for sleep. However, not all duvet comforters are made the same. Some lack duvet ties that help secure your comforter in a duvet cover. Others aren’t sewn in the best way possible. How do we pick the right one for our sleep? What’s the difference between a decent duvet comforter and a terrible one? In this buyer’s guide, we will look at what makes a good comforter and recommend the best of the best in the market.
Buyer’s Guide for the Best Comforter for Duvet
Choosing the right fill material and shell for you
Depending on your preferences, you might opt for the choice of a natural down comforter or a synthetic down alternative model. The benefits of both differ, and so too do the disadvantages.
Down comforters have the assurance of a chemical-free natural feel and sleep experience, but can be a noisy choice, not last as long as down alternative, and can be a pricier choice.
Down alternative are quiet and just as soft, and last longer. However, they don’t come with the same natural-feeling experience and breathability as down comforters.
Silk comforters have a luxury soft feel to the skin and breathes well, but the delicate fibers means they will show wear sooner than other types of material. They also don’t generally use duvet covers because it defeats the purpose of using silk: for its soft, luscious touch.
Wool can be a good choice as well for warmth and breathability, but we seldom see this even in clothing because they don’t feel great against the skin for many people.
There are also hybrid comforters that use cotton shell, but polyester filling. Although there is nothing wrong with such a choice (cotton is naturally hypoallergenic and antimicrobial), it’s worth knowing what type of fabric you are okay with and decide based on your personal preference first. We are, after all, finding the right cozy duvet comforter for you!
Duvet loops, tabs, and ties
Duvet comforters are comforters that are built to be used with duvet covers. They have loops, tabs, and ties for securing the perimeters of the comforter within the cover. This prevents it from slipping and sliding when you toss and turn at night. And less fixing and re-adjusting the comforter within the duvet cover, too!
Most comforters have corner tabs (4 in total), which are enough for duvet covers that have their own corner ties
Other models will also have duvet ties in the center of each side (8 in total), but you should check if your duvet cover needs this at all. The extra ties wouldn’t get in the way of sleep if you do end up with a comforter model that has these ties.
If a model doesn’t have duvet loops, tabs, and ties, don’t let that deter you! A good comforter is good. As long as you have no intention of playfully wrestling on your comforter, there shouldn’t be any irritating shifting within your duvet cover.
Decent fill power
Comforters have a range of fill power. Some around the 200 to 300 range; others, at the high 600-700
Fill power is the measure of loft or “fluffiness” of a comforter. Generally, the higher the number, the better the quality. This is because the down is denser thus fluffier and better at insulating you from the cold
If you are worried about feeling hot, you can pick a comforter that is below 500 in fill power. For the very cold sleepers, 600 or greater is the better choice.
Although this number is important, it isn’t the end-all-be-all to deciding on a quality comforter. We also want to know what filling and shell fabric the comforter is made of when deciding which is best for us.
Baffle box for cold times, sewn-through for the hot
Sewn-through box construction has a reputation for being low quality, but this isn’t necessarily true as they have their uses. They are the ideal choice for hot sleepers that need significantly breathable bedding and sewn-through box construction does just that. However, for cold sleepers or sleepers in need of a comforter for cold weather, sewn-through is not an ideal choice because the space between boxes do not insulate your body heat well enough.
When we speak of boxes, we are talking about the comforter design to keep the filling from shifting and clumping together. Manufacturers typically stitch sections to the comforter (waves, diamonds, boxes, etc.) in order to make the comforter useful in keeping you warm at night. You can picture how useless your comforter can be if your fillings shifted to one side of your comforter and leave one half of your body exposed during the night.
There are two main types of box-stitched construction: sewn-through and baffle box.
- Sewn-through comforters have their shell top layer sewn through to the bottom layer. They are less labor intensive, thus generally cheaper to buy. These types of comforters can be great for hot sleepers, but questionable in functionality. The filling isn’t able to expand close to the sewn-through edges in each box, leaving space for better breathing
- On the other hand, baffle box comforters require much more labor work and can cost significantly more. Between the top and bottom layer of a comforter shell are box walls that allow for fillings to hug. This eliminates the gaps in your comforter and allow the filling to fully insulate you as intended!
We generally recommend baffle box construction for most sleepers. They provide consistent and reliable temperature regulation and makes full use of down and down alternative filling. They also require quality stitching work, making the comforters better quality and longer-lasting. However, if you find yourself sleeping hot at night with nighttime sweating, then a sewn-through box-stitch design is the better choice.
Thread count considerations
Thread count measures the quality threading of the duvet comforter’s shell. The number represents how many horizontal and vertical threading is within a square inch. The higher the number, the finer the thread and the softer the touch. Generally, higher thread count is considered quality. Higher thread count comforters are more expensive because they require more labor to produce.
Most affordable comforters range between 200 to 300 in thread count. For most people, this is comfortable enough and higher thread count might not make a huge difference in feel.
More luxurious brand duvet comforters have a thread count of 400 or greater. Some even as high as 1000. As great of a soft touch high thread count might offer, finer threads are delicate and may have a shorter-life span if not properly maintained or used.
Keep in mind if you do use a duvet cover with your comforter, thread count might not play an important role in deciding which model is best for you. However, you can use this number as an indicator of a quality design.
Piped edges and double needle stitching for durability
Part of a quality design includes the stitch work done by the manufacturer. Two reliable indicators of such stitch work are the use of piped edges and double needle stitching. Although this doesn’t mean the particular model is perfect, piped edges and double needle stitching require extra labor to produce. What are the benefits of piped edges and double needle stitching?
Both prevent the seams along the perimeters of your duvet comforter from coming undone. The piping secures the edges and the double needle stitching reinforces it. The last thing we want to happen is for your comforter to explode, shedding all its fillings over your bed and bedroom floor. Piped edges and double needle stitching is almost a guarantee good work was done to make your particular comforter model.
Proper size for you and your bed
Ideally, you want your comforter to droop over the sides of your bed whether you are sleeping in it or not. The purpose of a comforter is to not only make you super cozy in bed, but also to keep you warm. An appropriately sized comforter prevents heat from escaping along the sides and ensures you continue to stay cozy
Be sure to take a look at the specific dimensions of each comforter. A good range is to take your mattress width and add 30 inches. This leaves 15 inches of droop along the sides of your mattress. For example, queen size mattresses are typically 60 inches wide. Queen size comforters are around 90 inches in width.
For the comforter hoggers, choosing a comforter on size larger than your mattress might be ideal. The height of your bed might also play a role in how large of a comforter you want. Also, you might not want your comforter to touch the floor!
Reviews of the Best Comforter for a Duvet
1. Best Fluffy Duvet Comforter – Royal Hotel Down Alternative Comforter
The Royal Hotel Comforter is our top choice as a duvet comforter. It is labeled as an Amazon’s Choice, meaning there are low return rates and higher customer satisfaction compared to other product models.
The photos are also not overly fluffy or manipulated so what you see is close to the real thing. This was one of the biggest points for us and many other reviewers who bought their best researched duvet comforter based on photos.
The Royal Hotel Comforter uses a natural cotton shell for improved breathability with synthetic polyester filling to keep warm at night. The shell has a thread count of 300 and the filling provides a fill power of 750+.
The comforter is also classified as a medium weight with the twin /twin XL size being 55 ounces in filling weight, queen 70 ounces, and king 86 ounces. The box-stitching uses baffle box design with walls separating the top and bottom layers of the shell.
As an added style bonus, the sides have a 1-inch gusset that adds a unique touch to the comforter while providing another bit of extra wall for down filling to expand against.
Allergens like pollen, dust mites, and mold can cause a lot of headaches and lead to terrible nights of sleep. Hypoallergenic bedding resist these allergens very well by providing a physical barrier between you and whatever it is that is causing your stuffy nose and breathing problems. They are also anti-microbial, too.
Hypoallergenic fabrics help seal in allergens so you don’t inhale them and make it difficult for dust mites to survive. It doesn’t mean you won’t ever have to clean your comforter, but it does you’ll have more nights without the bother of allergens. Hypoallergenic comforters are a must for those who suffer from allergies or asthma.
The Royal Hotel Comforter is a down alternative comforter, made with 100% natural cotton shell but with 100% polyester filling. These two materials are common on most comforters because they have hypoallergenic properties. If you react to goose or duck down and feathers, then this synthetic comforter with a natural shell can be a good alternative.
The soft touch and breathability of the cotton shell can not be overstated either. With a thread count of 300, it makes this comforter decent as a cover for keeping you consistently warm throughout the night.
True baffle box-stitch quilting
The comforter uses a baffle box design, and this allows the down filling to hug the interior walls of the comforter to ensure there isn’t any gaps for heat to escape. This makes the comforter consistent with its temperature regulation to keep your cozy during cold weather and winter nights.
The Royal Hotel Comforter can be used as a stand alone or with a duvet cover with tabs in each corner to help secure the duvet comforter insert in place. It’s also great as an all-season comforter, which is why we recommend it as our top pick! If you are a hot sleeper waking up from nighttime sweating, then this comforter is also ideal for you.
Sizes and dimensions
|Twin/Twin XL||68 inches x 90 inches||36 ounces|
|Full/Queen||90 inches x 90 inches||48 ounces|
|Queen-Oversized||92 inches x 98 inches||51 ounces|
|King/California King||106 inches x 90 inches||58 ounces|
|King-Oversized||110 inches x 98 inches||61 ounces|
2. Best Down Duvet Comforter – Egyptian Bedding Down Comforter
The Egyptian Bedding Down Comforter is one of the best down comforter duvet insert on the market. It has a ridiculously soft touch shell with a high fill power and baffle box construction. If you need a comforter that’s super warm and toasty, this model is it. Amazon’s given it a top Amazon’s Choice for indicating high satisfaction and low returns for goose down comforters.
Egyptian Bedding is a company that’s been around for years, with a selection of comforters made in different ways for picky sleepers. Many of the comforters are rated very positively and the reviews written demonstrate an equally positive experience.
The comforter is made with a high 1200 thread count shell with quality egyptian cotton. It has a fill power of 750+ with pure goose down clusters. The comforter uses true baffle box design for improved insulation and temperature consistency during sleep. It also has corner tabs and side loops that are great for securing within duvet covers. The comforter also uses gold trimmed piped edges to secure the perimeters of the comforter.
Egyptian cotton shell
Egyptian cotton is a luxury choice when compared to the average cotton because of its fine threads and soft silky touch. Because of the climate the cotton is grown in within Egypt, they allow for the fibers to become significantly longer than if the cotton was grown in cooler climates. The difference lies in the different plants the two are derived from, making them different in fabric quality.
Regular cotton is harvested with machinery and tend to be thicker in threading, which is why the typical comforter is between 200 to 300 thread count. Egyptian cotton is delicately hand picked to put less stress on the fibers, leaving them intact until processed and woven. The fibers tend to be longer, making fine yarns that can be woven together for high thread counts of 800 or higher.
Although the high 1200 thread count makes any type of cotton less durable, you get softness from the luxury high thread count and the Egyptian cotton material.
1200 thread count
Most comforters range between 200 to 300 in thread count. Occasionally you find comforters that are 800 or greater. 300 is a good number for most people, but you should still pick based on your own preference. Thread count indicates the number of threading horizontally and vertically within a square inch of a comforter’s shell (most comforters have box-stitch quilting that are around 12 inches by 12 inches).
The higher the thread count, the softer it feels against your skin. Once in a while, you find comforters like this particular model with an astronomical thread count of 1200. Let’s be clear: this doesn’t mean the comforter is amazing and there are tricks to inflate the thread count.
However, there is an exceptional case with this comforter as our second best recommended pick. This is also reflected in the low return rates (Amazon’s Choice label) and very positive reviews. If you want to sleep well, but find yourself struggling because of the cold weather, and want to wake up feeling refreshed, you can’t go wrong with the Egyptian Bedding Comforter.
Sizes and dimensions
|Twin||68 inches x 90 inches|
|Queen||90 inches x 90 inches|
|King||106 inches x 90 inches|
|California King||106 inches x 94 inches*|
* We couldn’t get any confirmation of the true dimensions of the California King. One shopper claimed the California King is 4 inches longer in length.
3. Best Down Alternative Comforter for Duvet – Utopia Bedding Down Alternative Comforter
Utopia Bedding is a quality brand with one of the best selling comforters on the market. The Utopia Bedding Down Alternative Comforter is a fluffy filled down alternative duvet insert with strong stitching and durable design so it can last for years. It would even longer when you use a duvet cover. The comforter has box-stitch quilting that gives the comforter the classic appeal while maintaining an even distribution of filling throughout. This will let you sleep better at night with a more consistent temperature without having your sleep disturbed by either the cold or the heat.
This comforter model is designed for year-round, all-season use as a hypoallergenic comforter. It comes uses 100% polyester shell with 100% polyester fiber that is treated with silicate material for anti-microbial and hypoallergenic properties. The comforter has 250 grams of filling per square meter, which is on the higher end for most comforters providing quality temperature control with a much denser (and fluffier) filling. The comforter also uses true baffle box design
Siliconized polyester fiber
Polyester fiber on its own is a great material for long-lasting use. It’s a synthetic material that takes chemically made polyester chips, melt them down, then spun to create whatever length and thickness, then treated for strength. Siliconization is an extra treatment step with a material called silicate that further resists dust mites and bacteria from attaching and growing within the strands.
The siliconization of the comforter’s filling makes it even further hypoallergenic by creating an additional physical barrier against pollen, dust mites, and mold. This is ideal for anyone who suffers from allergies.
Baffle box-stitch quilting
As we already know, baffle box construction offers the best warmth and consistent temperature regulation during sleep. It works by having a wall fabrics between each box, allowing filling to hug the walls and completely insulate the body so that heat can’t escape.
Contrast this with sewn-through box construction where there are no wall fabrics and the top layer shell is stitched through to the bottom layer shell. Although they still work well, especially as summer comforters or for hot sleepers, they won’t insulate as well as true baffle box designs.
The Utopia Bedding Comforter is one of the top rated comforters for hot sleepers, and works great as an all-season design for someone who needs a medium-weight comforter. The edges are also piped for extra strength and reliability and the comforter comes with corner loops (not tabs) that allow you to secure onto your duvet cover ties.
Sizes and dimensions
|Twin||64 inches x 88 inches|
|Queen||88 inches x 88 inches|
|King||102 inches x 90 inches|
4. Natural and Synthetic Blend – Globon Fusion Comforter
The Globon Bedding company has been around since 1998, producing quality bedding products both environmentally sustainable and fitting to trending tastes of consumers. Their products are natural, healthy, and like the case with their comforter, an interesting blend of durability and fluffiness. We’ll get more into this in just a moment. First off, specs!
The Globon Comforter is a blend between natural and synthetic fibers aimed at providing improved moisture absorption, breathability, and comfort. A hybrid comforter, if you will. It has 51% goose down and feathers filling with 49% Suprelle Cocoon polyester mix (more on this later). The breakdown of the goose down and goose feathers is kept a secret, so we can’t comment on this. However, it does have a high fill power of 650+, giving the comforter extra density for warmth and loftiness for the fluff that many sleepers love. It uses baffle box construction, has piped edges, and corner tabs for securing in duvet covers. The comforter is heavier than most models, but we would consider it as a medium-weight range. You can learn more about the fill weight in our sizes and dimensions chart below.
Suprelle Cocoon filling blend
The Globon Fusion Comforter has a 51% goose down and feathers fill with 49% Suprelle Cocoon polyester fill. The down and feathers provide significant fill power, but one of the drawbacks of these natural fillings is their shorter lifespan and durability compared to synthetic materials. This is where the Suprelle Cocoon filling comes in.
The Suprelle Cocoon filling is a special blend sourced from a European company called ADVANSA. This company has been involved in the development of polyester fibers for over 50 years, innovating in polyester fiber tech and producing quality polyester fibers for many different uses.
What makes this particular model of polyester fibers from ADVANSA unique is that it is supercharged in two particular benefits: extra loftiness and moisture absorbing. An independent authority group tested the Suprelle Cocoon fiberfill and found that it to have an extra 20% in loftiness compared to regular down filling. In addition, it has almost 3 times higher breathability than 100% natural products, giving you an improved sleep experience without the nighttime sweat.
For sleepers who are frustrated that their comforters isn’t nearly as fluffy as they expected, this is for you. Down comforters over time naturally lose loftiness as the natural material begins to age. However, synthetic fillings such as the Suprelle Cocoon can be revitalized through proper cleaning and maintenance, including professional laundry and re-fluffing from time to time.
The Globon Fusion Comforter also comes with a baffle box design for good temperature regulation and insulation (important for colder climates and weather), piped edges for durability along the perimeters of the comforter, and corner tabs for securing within duvet covers. This is one of the best comforter with duvet tabs as a medium-weight model, and makes it great for all-season use.
Sizes and dimensions
|Twin||68 inches x 90 inches||40 ounces|
|Queen||90 inches x 90 inches||50 ounces|
|King||106 inches x 90 inches||60 ounces|
5. Top Selling Down Alternative Pick – Beckham Hotel Collection 1300 Series Down Alternative Comforter
The Beckham Hotel Collection has one of the most popular comforters online. They sell many different comforters with each their own unique design and features. We found this comforter to be a great light-weight model for year-round use. If you are a hot sleeper, this hypoallergenic and hotel-like quality comforter is an ideal pick.
The Beckham Hotel Collection 1300 Series Comforter is a down alternative comforter that uses a polyester filling and shell. It is hypoallergenic, soft, and warm. It comes in 11 different solid colors, fit for any bedroom color scheme. The comforters are lightweight, designed for all-season, and great for summer weather or hot sleepers. It also comes at a decent price for its value.
Hypoallergenic for allergy sufferers
Your bed should be a sanctuary for sleep, where you feel safe, cozy, and well-rested. However, allergens can be sneaky and we might find ourselves bringing them into our bed.
Allergens include dust mites, molds, and mildew that cause our sinuses to lock up and clog our nasal passages. It makes your eyes water and causes general discomfort around your face. Although it’s nearly impossible to prevent them entirely, certain fabrics can help protect you better from such allergens.
Synthetic comforters are arguably the most ideal for those with severe allergies or have asthma. Polyester is anti-microbial, meaning they resist allergens and bacteria by not giving them anything to grow and foster on. The fabric weaving also provides a physical barrier to capture these allergens and prevent them from causing you headaches and stuffy noses during sleep.
Cotton fibers also work great as well, which is why we see them in other comforters. However, if you want a more durable and longer-lasting choice, polyester is the way to go. And Beckham Hotel Collection 1300 Series Comforter can give you just that, and a cozy bed to sleep in peace.
|Twin/Twin XL||68 inches x 90 inches|
|Full/Queen||88 inches x 88 inches|
|King/California King||104 inches x 98 inches|
6. Best Lightweight Comforter for Duvet – Puredown Down Comforter
The Puredown Down Comforter is a goose down and feather comforter that feels nice and fluffy. It’s a great comforter for year-round use, and some hot sleepers finding it a great lightweight choice for the cold weather and winter seasons. Although it’s not pure down, it breathes well, keeps you warm, and feels as natural as full goose down filling comforters.
This comforter model uses a natural cotton fabric for its shell with a stripe dobby pattern for a modern appeal. The thread count of the shell is 500, and has bright gold trimmings for piped edges for durability. The comforter uses a true baffle box design for consistent temperature regulation, and is filled with 75% goose down with 25% goose feathers. The fill power is a high 600 for decent fluffiness and good insulation. The comforter also has corner loops for securing inside duvet covers when used as a duvet comforter insert.
This is a relatively light comforter, classified as lightweight to medium-weight. Its smallest size (twin) fill weighing at 28 ounces and the largest size (king/California king) fill weight of 44 ounces. This comforter is ideal for sleepers who are comfortable with a little weight to keep them snug warm during sleep.
One of the most important parts of a good comforter is the quality stitch work done. Poor stitching leads to shedding, and the comforter eventually becoming useless when it’s ripped. The Puredown Comforter uses double needle stitching along the edges with piped edges to secure the edges and improve the longevity of the comforter, surviving natural wear and tear over time.
The comforter also uses a baffle box design and, as we mentioned in our buyer’s guide, provides a fully enclosed comforter system to keep you consistently warm throughout the night. The baffle box wall fabric allow filling to expand and fill the entire square (unlike sewn-through boxes), giving you full warmth cover and no gaps to minimize heat leaks. Baffle box also allows the filling to fluff up and give sleepers as much loftiness as the comforter can give. True baffle box design is regarded as a quality design feature for comforters.
|Twin||68 inches x 90 inches||28 ounces|
|Full/Queen||90 inches x 90 inches||37 ounces|
|King/California King||106 inches x 90 inches||44 ounces|
7. The Noiseless Down Alternative Duvet Insert – Superior Down Alternative Comforter
Superior manufactures a variety of products ranging from comforters to mattress toppers, to towels and bathrobes, and bed sheets and pillow cases. They have been around selling quality linens for over 40 years, including this great down alternative comforter model.
Although this comforter might not have tabs for tying to duvet covers, the Superior Comforter works great with as a duvet insert still. This down alternative model fits snug inside regular duvet covers with minimal shifting. It is also hypoallergenic and can be machine washed without much hassle (granted, washing is done so in the lowest tumble setting possible).
This comforter is a heavyweight model, with its smallest size (twin/twin XL) with a fill weighing of 60 ounces to the largest size (king) weighing at 100 ounces. The comforter is a hypoallergenic model with 100% polyester fibre as filling and polyester fabric shell. The comforter uses a baffle box design, with double needle stitching for durability, and feels smooth against the skin with its fine polyester fiber touch.
Noiseless, heavyweight design
Polyester has always been known as the “alternative” to true down. One of the important features of such microfiber filling and shells has to do with its hypoallergenic and antimicrobial properties. Sleepers sensitive to allergens sleep better with such bedding material because of the physical protection it offers to lock in allergens and provide an environment that resists bacteria.
However, another often overlooked reason for down alternative comforter is the noiselessness of the comforter, while keeping a natural comforter’s soft feel. Polyester can be produced as very fine threads, which gives it a soft touch that feels just like cotton, without the crunchy noises. Polyester filling also lacks structure unlike down and feather filled comforters, which reduces noise level disruptions when you toss and turn at night.
The heavyweight fill weight also makes the Superior a great choice for cold weathers. Some sleepers can rest well during a winter night time with temperatures between 10 to 30 degrees Fahrenheit. The comforter might not be ideal for sleepers who don’t enjoy the heavy sensation of a comforter, but is a great choice for bigger individuals or couples that want to sleep well and feel toasty during the coldest of times.
|Twin/Twin XL||68 inches x 90 inches||60 ounces|
|Full/Queen||88 inches x 90 inches||77 ounces|
|King||108 inches x 90 inches||100 ounces|